Nestled near Miami’s Main Street, Otter Cove, 232 S. Main St., is a restaurant that carries layers of history.
The building was originally a Texaco Gas Service Station. It was operated by the late Earl Sandmire, who began operating the Texas Oil Co. station in 1928. Sandmire ran the station for 40 years. About two decades ago, the Ottawa Tribe acquired the property, uncertain of its future, until Otter Cove Diner and Gift Shop breathed new life into the location.
A Gateway to Route 66 Nostalgia
Miami serves as a gateway to Route 66, featuring vibrant murals painted by locals that depict the city’s rich history and the spirit of the famous highway stretching from Illinois to California. Otter Cove complements this atmosphere, immersing visitors in nostalgia. The restaurant is filled with Route 66 memorabilia, showcasing artifacts and decor that tell stories of past road trips and historical stops.
Inside, the diner embraces its roots as a former gas station. Vintage car parts, like front grilles, are incorporated into the decor, blending seamlessly with the Route 66 and gas station themes. Additionally, the aesthetic honors Native American history, offering a unique spin that reflects the region’s heritage.
Food That Keeps You Coming Back
Otter Cove’s menu is packed with comfort food that delights travelers and locals alike. The restaurant burgers and sandwiches steal the show, with standout options like the Blackened Chicken Sandwich, Pulled Pork Sandwich, and Chicken Philly. One of their newer creations, the Hog-N-Heifer Burger, has quickly become a crowd favorite.
When it comes to desserts, Otter Cove shines with its famous milkshakes and a must-try peach cobbler. These treats are the perfect way to end a hearty meal.
A Gift Shop Full of Memories
Adjacent to the diner, Otter Cove’s gift shop offers Route 66-themed items, ranging from keychains and hats to picture frames and books. The shop also highlights the history and culture of the Ottawa Tribe, providing a meaningful connection to the area’s culture.
A Stop Worth Making
Located at 232 S Main St., Miami, Okla., 74354, Otter Cove is more than just a dining spot. It is a gateway to the past, offering a delicious meal and an introduction to Miami’s rich history. Whether you are traveling Route 66 or looking for a unique local experience, Otter Cove is a must-visit destination.
